The Heisman Trophy race has a distinct South Florida flavor this season.

Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith and Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney, both products of the South Florida high school football pipeline, currently sit first and second in the Heisman race, a remarkable storyline for the region long regarded as the richest talent hotbed in America.

Smith, the former five-star out of Chaminade-Madonna who was the No. 1 overall prospect in his class, has been nothing short of spectacular for the Buckeyes up to this point in his storied college career. Week after week, he has produced the kind of highlight-reel plays that define Heisman campaigns, torching secondaries and delivering consistently in the biggest moments for a national title contender. Smith has totaled 16 rec, 315 yds, and 3 TD'S thus far in 2026 including a statement game 164 Yards and 1 Touchdown on 8 grabs against No.4 Texas on September 12th.

Right on his heels is Toney, the electric Miami sophomore who has taken the nation by storm. Playing in front of his hometown crowd, Toney has showcased the speed, route-running polish, and playmaking ability that made him one of the most coveted recruits in the country out of American Heritage in 2025, although only a 3-star prospect after reclassing up to the Class of 2025. Toney has racked up 16 rec, 330 yds, and 4 TD's in 2026 through the first 2 games, those being @ Stanford and vs. FAMU. Toney, otherwise known as Mali, is doing it with a certain swag and flair that has South Florida and the Miami fandom rallying behind him every Saturday.

For a region that has produced legends at every level of the sport, seeing two of its own sit atop the Heisman conversation is a source of immense pride. From the youth fields of Miami-Dade and Broward to the biggest stages in college football, the 305 and 954 continue to prove that the best talent in the nation grows in South Florida.

The season is far from over, and the race will twist and turn through November. But right now, the path to the Heisman runs straight through South Florida, with Jeremiah Smith and Malachi Toney leading the way. FirstMan Sports will continue to track every step of the race.